You land a car dealership as a sponsor. Three weeks later, a different car dealership across town wants in too. Or you've got one orthodontist on your banner and a second one calls asking what it costs. This comes up more than people expect, and how you handle it affects both relationships. Here's a workable approach.
Decide your exclusivity policy before this happens, not during
The cleanest way to handle category conflicts is to decide your policy in advance and tell every sponsor upfront, rather than figuring it out in the moment when two businesses are both asking. There are really only two honest approaches:
- Category exclusivity, where one sponsor per category (one bank, one dentist, one car dealership) is the norm, usually at a higher sponsorship tier.
- Open categories, where you're willing to take sponsorship from multiple businesses in the same type of business, typically at a lower, non-exclusive tier.
Either is a legitimate choice. What causes real problems is not having a policy at all, and ending up promising (or implying) exclusivity to one sponsor while still being open to approach their competitor.
If you're offering exclusivity, price it accordingly
Category exclusivity is a real, valuable asset — a business is paying not just for their own visibility, but for their competitor's absence. That's worth more than a non-exclusive spot, and your pricing should reflect it. A sponsor who's paying a premium for exclusivity should get it in writing, with a clear definition of what category they're actually exclusive within (is a car dealership exclusive against all car dealerships, or specifically against other dealerships of the same brand?).
If a second business in the same category comes along
If you've already promised exclusivity, the answer is simple and non-negotiable: you tell the second business, honestly, that you already have a sponsor in that category under an exclusive agreement, and you're not able to bring in a competing business right now — but you're happy to keep them in mind for a different category, a future season, or if the existing sponsor doesn't renew.
If you haven't promised exclusivity, you're free to say yes to both — but it's still worth a heads-up to your existing sponsor rather than letting them find out their competitor is on the same banner. A quick "just so you know, we're also working with [competitor] at a different sponsorship level" avoids a sponsor feeling blindsided, even when they have no actual claim to exclusivity.
Watch for implied exclusivity, even when you never promised it
This is the most common version of this problem: you never explicitly promised exclusivity, but the sponsor assumed it anyway, because they're the only business in their category you've ever worked with. The fix is simple — if you're not offering exclusivity, say so plainly when you first pitch them, so there's no gap between what they assumed and what you actually agreed to.
When in doubt, let the first sponsor know before the second one signs
Even in an open-category situation, a short courtesy heads-up to your existing sponsor before a competitor comes on board costs you nothing and protects a relationship that's likely more valuable to keep than the awkwardness of staying silent would save you.
Setting a clear exclusivity policy — and pricing it properly — is something Zubie Five builds into every sponsorship package from the start, so this conversation never has to happen as an emergency.
Want help putting this into practice for your program?
Get Started With Zubie Five →